When I was little, we used to have stew and dumplings. The stew was sometimes good, sometimes terrible, but the dumplings were always tip-top. Big fluffy balls of tasty goodness, filling and comforting but not stodgy.
I've been trying to make dumplings like that every since I left home, and I just can't do it. Everybody, even quite experienced cooks, has a few culinary Waterloos lurking, and that's one of mine. (Other cooking tasks I will go out of my way to avoid include poaching an egg, icing fairy cakes, and carving pretty much anything in public). It's odd that I can't make dumplings, given my suet puddings and suet crust on pies are acknowledged to be pretty damn good. But there it is.
Then today I decided to have another try. It was so horrible and cold this weekend, so I made a big pot of beef stew and it was crying out for dumplings to go with it. So here we go.
The first recipe I tried was from Nigel Slater - he proposed plain flour, half as much suet as flour, and salt, and cold water to mix, then add to a pan of stock at a rolling boil. I wasn't going to risk my pot of stew (past horrors of dumplings dissolving into the gravy and ruining the whole pot put me off that idea) so I boiled a pan of water. The dumplings sank straight to the bottom, but did eventually rise to the top, and acquire some lightness.
But, you'd definitely call this batch stodgy. NOT the light and fluffy dumplings of my childhood. I remembered that in suet pastry I always add baking powder, so I tried again (luckily a few dumplings are very cheap)
with baking powder this time, and there was a definite improvement. But, during the boiling phase, two of the dumplings practically dissolved, and the survivors were still a bit soggy round the eddges.
At this point my other half strolled into the kitchen (no doubt wondering what was holding up the delivery of his stew, given all that was usually involved was ladling it out into a bowl), and mentioned he always balanced his dumplings on top of the stew to steam them. I did spend a minute trying to remember the last time that he cooked dumplings, or stew for that matter, but gave up and admitted he was probably right. You steam suet puddings, rather than boil them, at least I do, so it makes sense. I'm still not ready to steam them in my stew though - I think I might try a steamer basket or sieve first.
At least the second batch today were edible, if a bit on the damp side - which was fortunate because I was too hungry at that point to make any more.
The search for the perfect dumpling continues.